solution

CASE STUDY

The tyre case: Analysing your situation to make good pricing decisions

BY ELIZABETH GUNNER

CASE STUDY The tyre case: Analysing your situation to make good pricing decisions BY ELIZABETH...

Four different companies decide to enter the tyre market. Each company decides to produce a different product and, although their raw materials are exactly the same, the competition and demand for each market is quite different:

■ Company A produces standard car tyres: demand is high but there are lots of established competitor brands including a few large-scale producers that control prices.

■ Company B produces special tyres for army tanks: they are contracted by the government, and so they have only one customer and no competitors but the contract will be reviewed annually.

■ Company C produces tyres for four-wheel-drive vehicles: demand is lower than for standard car tyres, but there is less competition.

■ Company D produces tyres for fixed-gear bicycles: a growing market with few established competitors but with a growing number of new producers entering the market to meet growing consumer demand.

1 What are the different price-setting techniques that the companies could use to set their prices?

2 Select one pricing method for each firm and give a reason (or reasons) why you think this would be the most appropriate method.

3 Think about the differences in the customer base for each product. Which types of tyres would be more price elastic and why?

4 Carbon black is one of the key raw materials used to make tyres. The cost of carbon black has increased signi‑cantly, causing an increase in the production costs for all four tyre companies.

a Would this be an increase in fixed costs or variable costs?

b If all four companies raised their prices in response to the increased production cost, whose sales do you think would be most affected and why?

5 Company D is considering a temporary price promotion. List some scenarios where this could be a benefit for the company

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

CASE STUDY

A week in business-to-business selling

Bill Adams is a salesperson for a national manufacturer of packaging products, based in Melbourne, Australia. He is responsible for sales of corrugated cardboard boxes and packaging materials throughout the greater Melbourne area. Customers and potential customers include manufacturers of various products requiring standard or customised carton packaging. Some of his accounts are distributors rather than end-users. These distributors sell to relatively small users of corrugated products, typically being small business ­rms.
Bill’s typical working week starts with a 9am Monday morning sales meeting with his state sales manager and fellow salespeople, who sell a range of packaging products throughout the state of Victoria. This meeting normally takes about 90 minutes, perhaps longer if there are major issues to be discussed. Typically, the sales manager shares any new company information, while salespeople report any competitor or market information obtained from recent interactions with customers and other external contacts. Some time is also devoted to analysing sales trends. Finally, the sales manager provides a short motivational brie­ng. The meeting is held early each Monday as the sales manager believes this allows salespeople to start each week reinvigorated. The only other obvious alternative time would be Friday afternoons, when it is almost impossible to obtain appointments with customers or prospects. However, the sales manager prefers Monday morning when the salespeople are fresh, rather than when they are tired and looking forward to the weekend.
Bill spends the remainder of each week—until late Friday morning—visiting customers and prospects, occasionally contacting colleagues by phone or email to place new orders, or to follow up on issues raised in meetings with customers. He can’t imagine working ef­ciently without his iPhone and laptop! He summarises key issues discussed in each meeting, either before his next meeting or later in the day. Occasionally, he spends time in the sales of­ce working on sales proposals, usually discussing those with key staff from other areas within his ­rm and, for larger projects, with his sales manager.
Bill normally spends Friday afternoon reviewing his call reports relating to meetings with customers and prospects during the past week; updating follow-up items arising from those meetings, and any commitments he has made to customers that are still in progress; talking to relevant colleagues within customer service, production and delivery departments to identify any issues he needs to discuss with customers in the following week (he would have been advised earlier of any serious issues that required immediate follow-up with customers); and advising his sales manager of any issues of importance or requiring management advice or support. Finally, he checks his appointments for the next week, con­rming those for Monday and Tuesday via email (he con­rms others a day or two beforehand).
Today, Bill and his sales manager are meeting with a major prospect to present a proposal to supply customised packaging material currently purchased from a competitor. After discussions with his sales manager, Bill has based the proposal on quality of product, supply reliability and a commitment to work with the customer to develop a successful packaging system to assist in the marketing of the customer’s product. Following several meetings with various people within the customer organisation, the proposal has been developed during the past two weeks with input from a couple of technical specialists within Bill’s ­rm, as well as from Bill and his sales manager. Consequently, Bill feels con­dent about having strong technical and commercial content in the proposal

1. Comment on the level of support available to Bill and his sales colleagues, and what in‑uence that seems to have on his performance.

2. What are the likely reasons for Bill’s sales manager to be accompanying Bill to present this proposal?

3. How likely is the proposal to effectively address the major needs of the prospect?

4. Give suggestions to improve Bill’s sales productivity

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

Attempting to win new organisational customers or major supply projects can be expensive and take substantial periods of time. For example, the Australian Government’s SEA 1000 Future Submarine Project was identi­ed in a 2009 Defence White Paper; a Competitive Evaluation Process for the project was announced, and proposals were invited from French, German and Japanese ­rms in February 2015. Those proposals were due in November 2015 (ASC Pty Ltd, 2016). The successful bid, from French fi­rm DCNS, and valued at about AU$50 billion, was announced in April 2016.
The complexity and length of this process is not surprising given the large investment, complex hardware and software systems involved in the product, and strategic importance of the project. Consider who might be involved in the process within buyer and supplier organisations. After spending substantial time developing and presenting such a supply proposal, what would be the emotional impact on members of the unsuccessful selling teams? How might those emotions in‑uence the future selling performance of those individuals?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

CASE STUDY

The accounting partner

Paul Robinson is a partner in a medium-sized Melbourne accounting fi­rm, offering a range of accounting and fi­nancial advisory services. His ­rm’s largest client is a familyowned business in the largest regional town in the state.
Paul is the main point of contact with the client. Because of the client’s remote location, Paul makes a week-long trip to the town each quarter, occasionally with another partner or a senior manager from his fi­rm accompanying him. During these trips, Paul meets with the husband and wife who own and have senior management roles within the client company. He also meets with other managers of the fi­rm, particularly the ­finance manager, and various employees in the ­firm’s accounting and ­finance department.
The main reason for these visits is to maintain sound personal relationships and clear communication channels with the key contacts within the client company, particularly the owners and their senior managers. The second reason is to focus on any issues that have been identified since the last visit. Paul normally arranges to be accompanied by a colleague when any major issue is to be discussed—or, if no such issues develop, at least once per year for relationship development reasons.
Between visits, Paul typically talks to the fi­nance manager on an almost daily basis, as well as corresponding regularly via email. He also has various discussions with staff within his ­rm on a regular basis to ensure various accounting-related service matters are proceeding smoothly. If issues arise, Paul might meet with the relevant management and staff to address the issue before again communicating with client contacts.
Occasionally, the owners or senior managers from the client company visit Melbourne and, if they have time, they are hosted by Paul and perhaps another partner to a meal, again to maintain good customer relations as well as obtaining an informal update.
During the most recent visit by Paul and another partner from his firm to the client company, they spent substantial time discussing implications of a downturn in the client firm’s sales revenues and its financial impact. Discussions with the sales and marketing manager identified the key issue to be the loss of two major interstate customers. Every effort was being made to regain market share, but it was likely to take several months before revenue and profits were likely to start to increase above the current low levels. Paul and his partner spent significant time during this visit working with the sales and marketing manager and the finance manager estimating quarterly cashflow and profit forecasts for the following five years, based on different sales scenarios developed in consultation with the sales and marketing manager. Finally, the four of them presented financial projections to the two owners of the firm, identifying ‘worst case’ and ‘most likely case’ options. Paul and his partner then advised the owners and the finance manager how best to plan the firm’s financial arrangements given the cashflow projections. Finally, they advised what additional activities their accounting firm and the client’s finance department should undertake until the situation improved.

1. Paul Robinson and other partners of this accounting fi­rm clearly act at times as salespeople (or account managers), despite having accounting and ­finance quali­cations and no sales-related training. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this situation?

2. Do Paul and his partners fi­t the stereotypical view of salespeople? Do you think the key client contacts would view Paul and his partners as salespeople?

3. Given their lack of sales training, which steps in the selling process might Paul and his partners undertake least competently?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"