solution

CASE STUDY

Sophisticated mass marketing and the Model T Ford

There is a great deal of variety in markets:  customers vary, and so do marketing mixes. The idea that once upon a time there were companies that offered only a single marketing mix is undoubtedly a myth. The most commonly cited example of mass marketing a single product is the Model T Ford. And while it may have only come in the colour black (see previous case), there were also delivery and payment options, choice of dealers, and after-sales accessories. Between 1909 and 1927, 14 different body styles (such as four-door touring, or two-door sedan) were offered. Separate chassis were available for independent coach builders. On top of this, Ford also sold models of car other than the Model T.
Thus, we see that mass marketing has always involved some product-variety marketing, as well as some segmentation and targeting. This is still true today. Smart marketers are sophisticated mass marketers: they target all category buyers, working out clever, pro‑table ways to cater for meaningful differences in preference.
In 1914, Henry Ford chose to standardise the colour black for his product. His decision appears to have been justi‑ed, because the Model T went on to achieve a staggering 50 per cent global market share. At that time, most consumers were more concerned with price, durability and performance on the very poor roads of the time than with colour. Only later, when other cars could match the Model T’s performance, quality and price would colour become important to consumers. This example shows how marketers have to make careful decisions about catering for variation in preferences, understand what matters and what doesn’t, and formulate strategies of how to cater for that heterogeneity pro‑tably without losing sight of the real target—the market.

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

CASE STUDY

Hilti: From goods to service provision

Hilti is a Liechtenstein-based manufacturer of professional-standard power tools, such as electric drills, for companies in the building and construction industries. It was ­nding that many of these products were being seen as commodity items by its customers, and that customers were starting to buy cheaper competitor products. To address this situation, the company’s marketers reected on what were the core needs of its customers. They realised that building contractors need to ­nish their projects on time and get paid—if tools that are necessary to undertake work are not available, then a project may be delayed with possible ­nancial consequences. The Hilti marketers realised that they could meet the needs of contractors better by providing power tool use rather than ownership. Contractors do not necessarily make pro­ts from owning equipment but by being able to use it ef­ciently. Hilti responded by offering large building contractors a service whereby the contractor did not need to purchase the power tools outright. Instead, Hilti would guarantee to supply an inventory of the required set of well-maintained tools every day to a client’s construction site—for a fee. In this way, the building contractor would not have to buy, own and maintain the power tools, which was attractive to them. In fact, the client’s need was to have timely access to power tools, but not necessarily to own them. Hilti also bene­t by being able to ensure that their products are always working well and that they have a continuing income stream from companies with whom they maintain a regular relationship. Thus, a company that used to solely market equipment goods is now also

CASE STUDY Hilti: From goods to service provision Hilti is a Liechtenstein-based manufacturer of...

in a service business, but still uses the same products. To be able to meet the needs of building contractor companies in the new way, Hilti created a eetmanagement program for tools and, in doing so, moved its focus from that of production and manufacturing to servicing their customers’ needs.
This case illustrates the point that physical products may well be being acquired by customers to enable them to achieve what equally can be provided by a service. Marketers of companies that make physical products should ask themselves the question: Would it be better for our customer to use a service that we provide rather than acquire our products—and would it be better for our company?

1. How would you answer the question of ‘What business is Hilti in now?’

2. What are the marketing bene­ts to a company of being a supplier of core services to its customers rather than selling physical goods to them? What might be some disadvantages?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

CASE STUDY

My World My Way: Analysing the segmentation strategy

BY ELIZABETH GUNNER

The board of directors for Australian travel guide company My World My Way are concerned about declining market share. Scared of losing their number one position to Lonely Planet, they’ve hired a marketing consultant, who begins his ‑rst day with an inspiring presentation: ‘Meet Kev,’ he says, gesturing towards a projected image of a male in his late teens, with scu­ed shoes. ‘Kev is 18. He has two siblings and his parents are reasonably well o­. He’s pretty popular and spends his weekends playing club footy and going to parties with his mates. Kev’s just about to ‑nish school, and is desperate for some independence. That’s where we come in. Imagine that everywhere Kev goes, we are there saying “Hey, what about a gap year? Can’t you see yourself spending six months in Asia or South America? My World My Way guides are great for travelling on a budget.” Suddenly Kev’s got an idea. He starts buying guides and reading up. He asks mum and dad for a My World My Way backpack for Christmas. He “likes” us on Facebook and he talks about us with his friends …’
‘Kev is our future,’ concludes the consultant, ‘we know what he likes, where he goes, and how to talk with him. If we get Kev now, we’ve got him for life—every trip from his ‑rst to his last.

1. The marketing consultant is suggesting a highly targeted marketing strategy. What is the di­erence between a target marketing strategy and a mass marketing strategy?

2. Do you think a target marketing strategy is appropriate for My World My Way? What are the advantages and disadvantages in this instance?

3. Imagine you are the Marketing Director for Lonely Planet. What would you do in reaction to My World My Way’s new strategy? What are the opportunities and threats?

4. You have been hired as a consultant for My World My Way. The board hands you some survey results showing that lots of My World My Way customers are also buying other travel guides, even though they said that My World My Way is ‘great value for money’ and ‘an informative travel resource’.

a. a What can you tell the board about these results? Should they be concerned by these ‑ndings?

b. b What marketing advice would you give?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

CASE STUDY

Aspirations of luxury

Ysios is a brand of ­ne wine from the famous Rioja region of Spain. The winery is spectacular both inside and out. Designed by world-famous Spanish architect Santiago Calatrava, its roof dramatically reects the mountains and undulating vineyards of Rioja.
Bodega Ysios features state of the art wine-making facilities, including a temperature-controlled hall full of the ­nest new oak barrels for ageing the wine. Only two wines are made, both red, both 100 per cent Tempranillo. Tempranillo is the most famous grape of Spain—it is a ‘reserva', which means that under Spanish law it must spend at least two years in the winery before release, much of that time in oak. Ysios also makes a single vineyard Edición Limitada (limited edition) wine, of which only 9000 bottles are made, and then only in the best years.
Ysios is owned by Australian company Pernod Ricard Winemakers, owner of wineries such as Jacob’s Creek (Barossa, South Australia), Brancott Estate (New Zealand), and Kenwood Vineyard (USA). They also own Campo Viejo, a neighbouring Rioja winery that produces millions of bottles compared to the thousands for Ysios. Campo Viejo’s winery is impressive too, but for different reasons—it is underground, with impressive engineering rather than eye-catching architecture.
All of this wine group is part of French giant, Pernod Ricard, owner of spirits brands such as Absolut, Beefeater and Chivas Regal.
The small production scale of Ysios means that it presumably receives little attention from Pernod Ricard’s top management. Its sales and pro­ts are a minuscule part of the group’s ­nancial statements. The impressive winery is used for management meetings though.

In 2014, Christian Barré, president director general of Pernod Ricard’s Spanish wines, said: ‘For us Ysios is a luxury wine and has to be positioned as such’. However, he admitted: ‘In the past it was in between; the quality was good, the winery was fantastic but we felt it was missing a totally consistent and coherent message.
‘Three or four years ago we started to rethink the Ysios concept, the details of the vineyard, the barrels, Club Ysios. We have made dramatic selections in the vineyard and an additional selection for the Edición Limitada. You need to take care of every single detail.’
Making its ­rst move in Spain, the brand repositioned itself from the 2007 vintage, which involved a price increase from around €18 (AU$28), a level described by Barré as ‘clearly too cheap’, to €25 (AU$38).
With the focus now shifting abroad to China, where it will sell for the equivalent of around $120 per bottle, Barré suggested that the US has the potential to become another strong market for Ysios.
Setting out a ‘target price’ of $50 per bottle in the US market, Barré identi­ed the potential Ysios consumer in the US as ‘the ones drinking Pingus or Vega Sicilia today’.
Despite its position as a major hub for the ­ne wine market, Barré suggested that the UK was not likely to form a signi­cant focus for Ysios. ‘In the UK we just sell a few cases and will probably remain small for select consumers who enjoy having a good selection of the best wines from Spain,’ he remarked.

1. More than eight years later, in 2016, Ysios Reserva 2008 still sells for as low as €18 (AU$28) in Spain and seldom more than €25 (AU$38). Following is a selection of reviews from the CellarTracker website:

• ‘Very modern, clean, expensive oak, good concentration. A straightforward corporate wine though. I knew Rioja could be bad (simple commercial dollied up with vanilla oak, or more serious wine spoiled by far too long in musty old oak). And also quirky, and/or GREAT. But I didn’t know Rioja could be boring.’

• ‘This is a very smooth crowdpleaser. Cherry liquor, dark chocolate and sweet tobacco. Silky and rich with a bright acidity intense dark berry avor and long ­nish. Alcohol is not very balanced.’

• ‘Fantastic tour at the winery. On the nose, oak, smoke and red fruit. On the palate, smooth cherry oak mild acid. No tannin. Medium ­nish.’

Could the problem be product quality? Go to the website and compare reviews for Ysios Reserva 2008 to reviews for Vega Sicilia. What else might be a problem?

2. The marketing staff at Ysios would like to increase sales volume as well as the price. What challenges do they face? What assets do they have to build upon?

3. Comment on the plans to sell for €25 in Spain, $50 in the USA and $120 in China. Is this realistic? Is this a good marketing strategy?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"