solution

CASE STUDY

Iron‑sh

BY BILL PAGE

Marketing matters in places you wouldn’t expect. Social marketing is the application of marketing principles to achieve social change—such as wearing seatbelts, saving water or wearing sunscreen. It is often used when the need for change is well accepted, but getting people to engage in the new behaviour is dif­cult. Traditionally, social marketing has involved the application of conventional marketing to social issues, but it has developed its own vocabulary, ideas and tools (Peattie & Peattie, 2003). Social marketing is used to inform and educate, create behaviour change, lobby for bene­cial laws and achieve social advocacy (Donovan, 2011).
In Cambodia, much of the population suffers from anaemia and need to get more iron in their diet. Forty-­ve per cent of women in Cambodia suffer from iron de­ciency, which usually just means listlessness and tiredness in Western countries, but in extreme cases can lead to poor brain development in babies, premature birth and uncontrolled bleeding during childbirth. Across the developing world, serious anaemia affects 2 billion people—it’s a major problem, and doing something to help these people could improve their lives.
In wealthy countries, iron de­ciency can be easily treated by eating more red meat or by taking iron supplements, but both options cost far too much for developing nations. Cast iron releases itself when used for cooking, and cast iron pots impart enough to help combat anaemia, but they are heavy and expensive so it is dif­cult to convince the women of Cambodia to use them. Cost and convenience are common barriers to change.
Like all good marketing, the Iron­sh campaign began with market research. By consulting with ‘key informants’ who were willing to talk to outsiders, such as the wives of village elders, researchers were able to understand more about why iron pots aren’t popular. A problem previous researchers hadn’t considered was that there’s no Tupperware (or equivalent) in rural Cambodia: people often leave food in the pots to eat later, and the iron makes the food taste bad.
Biomedical scientist Chris Charles and his team from the University of Guelph found an alternative: simply including a lump of iron in a cooking pot gives enough iron to combat anaemia, and it can be taken out and used again in other cooking. But the ugly shape of the lump and the strange idea isn’t very appealing, despite the health bene­ts.
‘We knew some random piece of ugly metal wouldn’t work … so we had to come up with an attractive idea,’ notes Charles. ‘It became a challenge in social marketing.’
To determine the shape of the cast iron they would promote to the village, research again played a key role. More interviews with key informants were conducted, and three potential designs were tested in focus groups. The lumps needed to have the minimum weight and maximum surface area, to be made as cheaply as possible and to impart the greatest amount of iron into the food. The possible designs were a at disc, a lotus ower—which holds a special place in Cambodian culture—and a lucky ­sh from the Mekong River, which runs through the area. The ­sh proved the most popular in testing
‘We designed it about 3 or 4  inches long [8–10  cm], small enough to be stirred easily but large enough to provide up to about 75 per cent of the daily iron requirement,’ said Charles. The fish are made locally for about $1.50, and last for five to ten years.
The team combined their ­sh with an education program designed to explain what anaemia actually is, and why they should use the ­sh itself. To help get the message out and remind people to use their iron ­sh they ran an advertising campaign involving hats, T-shirts and posters put up around the village. After the barriers of cost and convenience had been eliminated through careful research and design, the information and education campaign was useful in creating awareness of the problem and ensuring that villagers saw a need to use the iron ­sh.
Research played one ­nal important role in the iron­sh’s adoption. It helped to identify that a key barrier to consistent usage was that people thought of it as a medicine, so kept it with the rest of their medicines—up high, where it was dry and safe. Of course, if it’s kept locked away, it’s not doing anyone any good. This research ­nding led to additional education encouraging people to keep it next to the cooking area, instead of with the medicines.
‘We’re now getting fantastic results; there seems to be a huge decrease in anaemia and the village women say they feel good, no dizziness, fewer headaches. The iron ­sh is incredibly powerful.’
The results achieved by the iron­sh are far greater than anything done with expensive iron pots. The increased time spent in research and development was easily justi­ed by the improvement in results. So, by combining medical knowledge with market research, Cambodian people no longer suffer anaemia as badly.
Charles is heading back to Cambodia to follow up with the women and check their iron levels. He expects that most of the women will still be using the ­sh—but as usual, we await more research to ­nd out how successful it has been. What was the main thing these biomedical scientists learnt about the role of research in informing marketing? ‘You can have the best treatment in the world, but if people won’t use it, it won’t matter.’

1. Market research played a critical role at different points in addressing this medical issue. Identify what these roles were and discuss their importance.

2. Can you think of a similar social problem where market research might play a useful role?

3. Can you think of a product or service that was either created or improved in response to market research?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

CASE STUDY

Choosing appropriate methods

You are the marketing manager of the Gold Class movie offering for Event Cinemas in Australia. You want to commission market research to gain an understanding of how satis­ed Gold Class movie-goers are with your offers in South Australia, including the mix of movies, refreshment services or bar, ticket of­ce, ambience, quality of video and sound, special sessions, website etc. Different research methods are presented to you.

1. Observational research is conducted with every fourth visitor to the Gold Class cinema in Marion, South Australia. The researcher will follow the visitor around, observing and recording exactly what the visitor does until they leave the cinema.

2. Leave a pile of self-completion questionnaires at the entrance of the Gold Class cinema with a notice telling of a chance to win a book of 10 movie tickets (not Gold Class) if the questionnaire is completed and put in the return box next to the questionnaires.

3. Show a short advertisement before each movie encouraging visitors to go online and complete a short questionnaire for a chance to win a weekend in Robe.

4. Interviewers administer the questionnaire face to face in the Gold Class area on every Sunday for a month. Interviewers determine whom they will ask to participate.

5. Have a pop-up survey on the Event Cinemas website, asking for feedback.

1. Assess the representativeness, likely response rate, quality of the data and other research issues associated with each approach. How could you improve each?

2. Propose your own method for this research, and explain its pros and cons.

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

CASE STUDY

Tapping into social media chatter

Is the monitoring of social media sites a substitute for research? Social media tools such as consumer forums, blogs, Facebook, Google+ and Twitter provide platforms for people to talk about the brands and products they use—and therefore provide opportunities for organisations to monitor what is being said about their brands. They also provide data. Instead of asking consumers what they think in market research surveys, organisations can listen in to what consumers are saying online.
However, there are some problems with this approach. Here are some of the issues to consider.

1. Do people really talk about brands?

People do talk about brands and products that are part of their everyday lives— Google, Apple, Coke, McDonald’s and Facebook are among the most talked-about brands. But people talk more about these brands in the ‘real’, ofine world, than online. The word-of-mouth measurement tool TalkTrack estimates that 76 per cent of ‘branded’ conversations occur face to face (Keller & Libai, 2009), so monitoring online chatter only captures a small fraction of the conversations that happen every day

2. Who is doing the talking?

Research ­rm Forrester has found that a very small minority of people (6 per cent) account for the vast majority (80 per cent) of all brand impressions on social networks such as Twitter and Facebook (Keller, 2011). On Facebook, fewer than 1 per cent of fans engage with the brands they befriended, and even fewer comment or say anything interesting at all about the brand in any given week (Nelson-Field & Taylor, 2012). This means that the opinions through social media monitoring come from a few disgruntled or enthusiastic chatterboxes. The sample is unusual, so the ‘data’ is unlikely to be representative of the opinions of all users or people.

3. What are people talking about?

Finally, social media monitoring is unlikely to provide deep insight into what people really think about brands and products. Online discussions about brands are typically aimed at providing advice to other consumers, not outlining deeply held brand beliefs or describing behaviours (Mangold, Miller & Brockway, 1999). Furthermore, most comments are positive in nature, which is different from the data obtained through representative survey research. Bourque, Hobbs and Hilaire (2011) examined more than 10,000 comments made online about a brand of coffee machine and compared them to the results of a large online survey. They found that social media commenters said more positive things, not because they were nicer or more honest, but because they were simply more likely to be users of the brand than survey respondents. This demonstrates that the sample provided by social media monitoring is skewed.

1. What are the key issues with using social media monitoring as a research method? What are the issues with coding and interpreting the data; the sample; meeting research objectives; and generating usable research outcomes?

2. Is social media monitoring suitable for determining how much people are talking about a brand or product?

3. If a brand monitors its social media mentions for a month, how large is the sample likely to be? Who is likely to be included in the sample? Will it be biased? Based on your understanding of sampling theory and techniques, is monitoring social media mentions a good sampling approach?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

solution

Case Study

iSnack2.0

Vegemite, the yeast concentrate spread, is an Australian household breakfast staple. It was invented in 1922, and each year over 22 million jars are sold. It is used on toast and crumpets, in sandwiches and as a cooking ingredient. The billionth jar of Vegemite was produced in 2008. On 13 June 2009, Kraft released a new version of Vegemite, which contained Vegemite and cream cheese. A competition was run to give the product a name. The winning name was iSnack2.0, and it was announced during the AFL Grand Final. The winning name was chosen by marketing and communication experts to appeal to the younger market with its association with iPods and iPhones.
The reaction was immediate and strong, with industry likening the backlash to that seen when Coca-Cola changed its Coke recipe and rebranded it as New Coke. Just four days later, Kraft announced plans to abandon the name, with the Head of Corporate A‑airs admitting ‘the name isn’t resonating with success or favour’.

Case Study iSnack2.0 Vegemite, the yeast concentrate spread, is an Australian household breakfast...

A new name, ‘Vegemite Cheesybite’, was announced in October that year, after the company posted six new alternatives and asked the public to vote on them (see Figure 4.4).

Glad Wrap and its cutter bar

Glad Wrap, Australia’s number one clingwrap, recently changed the location of the cutter bar from the outside to the inside of the box. It claimed this was done after extensive market research. On 14 January 2015, GLAD wrote on its Facebook page:

In light of the recent complaints we have received about the new position of the cutter bar on the GLAD ClingWrap box, we would like to take this opportunity to shed some light on the reasoning behind the change. All changes were made in response to customer feedback, with the intention of improving the value and usage experience. We wanted to give our customers a much better experience and better value, at no extra cost.

Before making these changes, GLAD completed rigorous and extensive in-home research in Australia, receiving positive feedback from Australians who participated in the research. However, we are actively listening to our loyal customer base, taking the current feedback concerning the new cutter bar location very seriously and this is currently under review.
However, shortly afterwards GLAD posted this on its Facebook page on 21 January 2015:

We would like to thank you for providing your invaluable feedback during this time, and will keep you posted with any updates. Thanks.
Following the overwhelming amount of feedback we have received, we are pleased to announce that we are going to change the cutter bar on all our Cling Wrap products back to its original location.

1. What lessons can be learnt from these two examples about how market research can help to reduce risk in decision making?

2. What research would you suggest should have been done before deciding on the new Vegemite name and the GLAD cutter bar change?

3. How did research play a role in the renaming of iSnack2.0 and the relocation of Glad Wrap’s cutter bar?

4. Do you think the company approached the second go at naming iSnack in the best way? Why or why not?

5. Why do you think the research results for Glad Wrap’s new cutter bar were so different from their customers’ response?

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"