solution

AFLAC, Inc., hired Peter Williams, an attorney. under a seven-year contract to give the company legal advice as needed. The contract provided that if AFLAC terminated the relationship, it would pay Williams 50 per- cent of whatever amount was due for the remaining term. After four years, AFLAC terminated the contract with Williams and asked a Georgia state court to determine the enforceability of the termination payment provision. The court declared the provision unenforceable, and Williams appealed. The state appellate court reversed this decision, and AFLAC appealed. ISSUE Does a contract clause that requires a client to pay his or her attorney unreasonably high damages for discharging the attorney consti- tute an improper penalty? DECISION Yes. The Supreme Court of Georgia, holding that the provi- sion was an unenforceable penalty clause, reversed the decision of the intermediate appellate court. REASON The state supreme court explained that the contract “requires AFLAC to pay an unreasonably high sum as damages, requires payment without considering Williams’ duty to mitigate his damages, and obligates AFLAC to pay even if Williams is discharged for cause.” Thus, the provi- sion “is not a reasonable estimate of Williams’ damages and instead is a penalty imposed to punish AFLAC.” FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS-Ethical Consideration Why shouldn’t parties to a contract be allowed to agree to the imposition of whatever penalty they wish in the event of a breach?
 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"