solution
STATE O SEAL OF GREAT IN GOD WE TRUST FACTS Cudlipp Construction and Development Company agreed to build up to 375 houses for Shadow Lakes, Inc., near Tampa, Florida. Under the contract te parties were bound to complete fourteen of the houses but either party had the right to terminate the agreemen with regard to future houses if prices could not be mus ally agreed on by the parties. For each house, Shadow Lakes agreed to pay a fixed price, which included the costs of construction and a fee to Cudlipp’s services. The contract indicated that the fee covered “off-sne and on-site supervision, office overhead and general support,” as well as Cudlipp’s profit-which, according to Cudlipp’s testimony at trial-was to be $10,000 per house. Problems developed between the parties ate Cudlipp had begun to construct eight houses. Cudlipp filed a suit in a Florida state court against Shadow Lakes, alleging, among other things breach of contract. The damages Cudlipp sought included lost profits of $3,670,000 ($10,000 for 367 houses—375 houses less the 8 houses already under construction). The jury awarded Cudlipp $3,670,000 in los profits, and Shadow Lakes appealed. ISSUE Was $10,000 an accurate figure for the amount of Cudlipp’s lost profits for each house? DECISION No. The District Court of Appeal of Florida reversed the award and remanded for a new trial on the amount. REASON The state appellate court concluded in part that the amount of profit to be realized on each home was “speculative.” Additionally stated the court, “Whether or not the parties would have come to a meet- ing of the minds regarding other houses beyond the original fourteen is pure speculation and conjecture. Not only did the parties have to agree on price, but the acreage needed for the project had to be purchased by Shadow Lakes.” The court pointed out that the contract indicated, and Cudlipp later acknowledged, that “certain overhead and other expenses should be subtracted from the $10,000 per house. Moreover, Cudlipp’s owner testified that “the $10,000 figure also included possible upgrades to the houses by the ultimate purchasers.” FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS-Economic Consideration What might be an appropriate measure of damages if in fact a contractor was realizing no profit, or was even actually losing money, on a contract?
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

