SW Airline Analysis Assignment

Southwest Airlines Analysis Assignment

· APA format

· At least 5 in text citations

· Must include a SWOT analysis at the beginning. Strengths must include firm’s market share and weakness include the firm’s cost trends.

· Each paragraph should answer each of the bullets.

· What do you find impressive about Southwest Airlines? Four examples needed

· What would you grade Southwest’s management strategy, what do you dislike or like about the strategy, do they have a winning strategy, explain.

· Key policies, operating practices, procedures, and values underlying Southwest’s efforts to execute and implement its low-cost strategy.

· Is Southwest a strong-culture company? Explain. What are key elements to Southwest’s culture? What problems do you see for Gary Kelly in sustaining the culture now that Herb Kelleher has departed?

· What grade would you give Southwest management for the job it has done in implementing and executing the company’s strategy? Which of Southwest’s strategy execution approaches and operating practices do you believe have been most crucial in accounting for the success that Southwest has enjoyed in executing its strategy? Are there any policies, procedures, and operating approaches at Southwest of which you disapprove or that aren’t working well?

· What weaknesses or problems do you see at Southwest Airlines as of mid-2010?

· Does the AirTran acquisition make good strategic sense for Southwest?

· What strategic issues and problems must Gary Kelly and Southwest executives address as they proceed to close the deal with the AirTran acquisition and contemplate how best to integrate AirTran’s operations and AirTran’s employees into Southwest?

· What recommendations would you make to Gary Kelly and Southwest executives as the company heads into the next year?

 

No minimum word/page. MUST BE ORIGINAL

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

Errors In Reasoning

M2 Assignment 2 SubmissionAssignment Task: Submit to complete this assignment Due June 27 at 11:59 PM

Assignment 2: Errors in Reasoning

In this assignment, you will select one of the topics listed below. Using what you know about the topic, describe at least four claims that might commonly be made that display some of the errors in reasoning covered in this module’s readings. You may have to do a bit of research to find popular positions on these topics.

For example, if the claim is: Children should not be allowed to play violent video games.

Then four common claims about the subject might be:

  1. Children have always played violent games and they turned out okay.
  2. Dr. Dre says that violent video games are okay.
  3. Everybody knows that violent video games don’t cause problems.
  4. Many countries banned violent video games and they have higher crime rates than we do.

And the errors they represent might be:

  1. Children have always played violent games and they turned out okay (appeal to tradition and false analogy).
  2. Dr. Dre says that violent video games are okay (argument by mistaken authority).
  3. Everybody knows that violent video games don’t cause problems (appeal to common belief).
  4. Many countries banned violent video games and they have higher crime rates than we do (post hoc ergo propter hoc).

Because

  1. Any sentence that talks about how we have always done something as a way to justify doing it is an appeal to tradition.
  2. The claim looks like it comes from an authority, but Dr. Dre is a musician, not a doctor.
  3. Any claim that says that everyone knows something as a way to justify doing it is an appeal to common belief.
  4. Showing that two things happened (that video games are accepted and crime is up) does not prove that the two things are related or that the first caused the second; this is called post hoc ergo propter hoc, which means after this, so because of this.

Select one of these topics. Using what you know about the topic and additional research you conduct, describe at least four claims that might commonly be made that display some of the errors in reasoning covered in this module’s readings.

  1. Should people under 18 be subjected to legal curfews or restricted driving privileges?
  2. Should libraries be required to install filtering software or otherwise censor the materials that they provide?
  3. Should insurance companies be required to pay for breast reconstruction, birth control pills, or Viagra?
  4. Should the use of camera phones be banned in gymnasiums or other locations?

Write your 600-word response in the Microsoft Word document format.

Assignment 2 Grading Criteria Maximum Points

Provided at least four commonly made claims about your selected topic (four common claims).40

Named the errors found in each common claim (the errors represented).30

Explained what factors show that the error is present (definitions).20

Applied current APA standards for editorial style, expression of ideas, and format of text, citations, and references. Professionally presented the response by using good grammar, spelling, and punctuation.10                 Total:100 pts

Module 2 Overview (2 of 3)

Needs Assessment

There are three levels of needs assessment or analysis. They are organizational, job, and individual.

Organizational Analysis—- In organizational analysis, organizational effectiveness is examined, and areas of improvement are determined.

Job Analysis—– A job analysis can provide information about employee knowledge, skills, and attitudes that are necessary for optimal performance in each type of job.

Individual Analysis—- An individual analysis indicates how well an employee is performing, which employees need training, and what kind of training is needed.

 

 

 

 

Examine the elements required to maximize the outcomes of a performance management system.

Evaluate the theory, research, and practice related to employee training and career development programs.

The first phase in the training design process is the training needs assessment (or analysis). The needs assessment is used to assess organization training needs by highlighting knowledge and skill gaps. There are many ways to conduct the needs assessment, which depends on the organizational situation and circumstances.

 

 

The assessment begins with a need, which can be identified in a number of ways, but is basically defined as the gap between the current and desired states. Gaps may occur between what an organization expects to happen versus what is actually happening, for example, existing and desired skills and competencies or existing and desired performance.

 

The needs assessment can be useful in identifying competencies and performance of work teams, performance and problem-solving issues, and critical strategies for responding to future changes in the organization or job responsibilities.

Module 2 Overview (3 of 3)

The results of a needs assessment help training professionals to establish training objectives. However, sometimes training is not the solution to issues that can be resolved through more effective communications, job fit, and a more supportive work environment.

 

Once needs assessment has been completed and training objectives clearly identified, the design phase of the training process commences. This phase involves identifying an appropriate trainer or resource, program content, training methods, training location or setting, and training materials.

 

After the design phase is completed, it is time for the implementation phase which includes scheduling sessions, participants, trainers, and facilities; preparing materials; and conducting the training. The final phase of the training and development process is evaluation, which indicates whether the objectives were achieved, the participants’ reactions to the training, and the level of learning that occurred.

 

In this module, you will explore the phases in the training design process.

From the textbook, Employee training & development, 7th, read the following chapters:

Needs assessment

Learning and transfer of training

Program design

 

https://digitalbookshelf.argosy.edu/#/books/1260050858/cfi/6/32!/4/2/24/10/80/2@0:34.5

Chapter Three

Needs Assessment

Objectives

After reading this chapter, you should be able to

 

Discuss the role of organization analysis, person analysis, and task analysis in needs assessment.

Identify different methods used in needs assessment and identify the advantages and disadvantages of each method.

Discuss the concerns of upper- and mid-level managers and trainers in needs assessment.

Explain how personal characteristics, input, output, consequences, and feedback influence performance and learning.

Create conditions to ensure that employees are receptive to training.

Discuss the steps involved in conducting a task analysis.

Analyze task analysis data to determine the tasks for which people need to be trained.

Explain competency models and the process used to develop them.

Needs Assessment at B&W Pantex and MasTec

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

BZ440 Lesson 4 & 5 Exam

The key to ___________ courage was his unbounded optimism.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Churchill’s

 

   

b) 

Lincoln’s

 

   

c) 

Truman’s

 

   

d) 

Roosevelt’s

 

Question 2

Many of today’s managers have a mindset that employees should do what they are told, when they are told, and how they are told. Such a value system is known as:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

fear of losing control.

 

   

b) 

status syndrome.

 

   

c) 

I’m-the-boss syndrome.

 

   

d) 

old-school syndrome.

 

Question 3

Prompt ___________ suggestions for improvement is essential to the success of empowerment.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

review of

 

   

b) 

implementation of

 

   

c) 

feedback on

 

   

d) 

demonstration of

 

Question 4

Which of the following strategies will help organizations move beyond empowerment to enlistment?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Set up a reward system.

 

   

b) 

Make it clear to all employees     that their ownership is not just wanted and needed but that it is expected.

 

   

c) 

Make it clear to implement     suggestions.

 

   

d) 

Empower employees for     suggestions that are implemented.

 

Question 5

The primary inhibitor of empowerment is:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

theWohcao Syndrome.

 

   

b) 

human nature’s resistance to     change.

 

   

c) 

resistance from employees and     unions.

 

   

d) 

resistance from management.

 

Question 6

___________ leadership is also known as consultative leadership.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Democratic

 

   

b) 

Participative

 

   

c) 

Situational

 

   

d) 

Autocratic

 

Question 7

The change facilitation model contains which of the following steps?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Develop a compelling change     picture

 

   

b) 

Conduct a comprehensive     roadblock analysis

 

   

c) 

Monitor and adjust

 

   

d) 

All of the above

 

Question 8

Which of the following is NOT a component of The Juran Trilogy?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Quality planning

 

   

b) 

Quality control

 

   

c) 

Quality assessment

 

   

d) 

Quality improvement

 

Question 9

The key to motivating people lies in the ability to relate their personal needs to the organization’s:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

mission.

 

   

b) 

vision.

 

   

c) 

initiatives.

 

   

d) 

goals.

 

Question 10

The word that best describes management’s role in employee empowerment is:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

facilitation.

 

   

b) 

leadership.

 

   

c) 

commitment.

 

   

d) 

All of the above

 

Question 11

Which of the following is an element of management’s role in empowerment?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Commitment

 

   

b) 

Establishing quality circles

 

   

c) 

Establishing customer feedback     mechanisms

 

   

d) 

Being impatient to earn employee     buy-in

 

Question 12

Employee empowerment is:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

employee involvement in decision     making.

 

   

b) 

employee input that is heard,     seriously considered, and followed up on whether it is accepted or not.

 

   

c) 

power of the employee to make     suggestions that will be reviewed by management.

 

   

d) 

power of the employee to make a     decision without management involvement.

 

Question 13

___________ suggests that anything that can go wrong will go wrong.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

The Juran Trilogy

 

   

b) 

Maslow’s Hierarchy

 

   

c) 

Murphy’s Law

 

   

d) 

Truman on leadership

 

Question 14

One of the main reasons why people in organizations resist change is fear of:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

failure.

 

   

b) 

competition.

 

   

c) 

the unknown.

 

   

d) 

multitasking.

 

Question 15

___________ is the phenomenon that exists when people in a group focus more on reaching a decision than on making a good decision.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Consensus

 

   

b) 

Brainstorming

 

   

c) 

Groupthink

 

   

d) 

Walking and talking

 

Question 16

The ___________ is made compelling by writing it from the perspective of the stakeholders it will be communicated to.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

process plan

 

   

b) 

mission statement

 

   

c) 

corporate vision

 

   

d) 

change picture

 

Question 17

Trust-building strategies include all of the following EXCEPT:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

being consistent.

 

   

b) 

providing employee enrichment.

 

   

c) 

pitching in and helping.

 

   

d) 

taking the blame but sharing the     credit.

 

Question 18

The most effective leaders can be found in what part of an organization?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Top-level management

 

   

b) 

Mid-level management

 

   

c) 

Lowest paid wage earner

 

   

d) 

All of the above

 

Question 19

Which of the following is a benefit of mentoring?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Enhances performance

 

   

b) 

Satisfies ISO 9000 standards

 

   

c) 

Decreases the organization’s     retention rate

 

   

d) 

Eliminates the problem of     stewardship

 

Question 20

Which of the following characteristics will help build and maintain followership?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Autocratic attitude

 

   

b) 

Goal-oriented attitude

 

   

c) 

Competitiveness

 

   

d) 

Sense of purpose

 

Lesson 5 Exam

   

Question 21

When putting together a team, the first step is to:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

determine the team’s purpose.

 

   

b) 

create the team’s charter.

 

   

c) 

identify all potential team     members.

 

   

d) 

focus on team processes.

 

Question 22

The most important factors that combine to magnify the need for training are global competition, rapid and continual change, quality of the existing labor pool, technology transfer problems, and:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

quality of organization.

 

   

b) 

changing demographics.

 

   

c) 

change in productivity.

 

   

d) 

corporate image.

 

Question 23

The oldest and most used method of teaching is the __________ method.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

demonstration

 

   

b) 

conference

 

   

c) 

lecture/discussion

 

   

d) 

simulation

 

Question 24

A group of people become a team when:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

members adhere to team ground     rules.

 

   

b) 

fair distribution of     responsibility and authority exists.

 

   

c) 

people adapt to change.

 

   

d) 

All of the above.

 

Question 25

A fundamental premise of leadership is:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

reward/recognition.

 

   

b) 

setting a positive example.

 

   

c) 

controlling workplace conflict.

 

   

d) 

using collaboration as a guiding     principle.

 

Question 26

Which of the following is NOT classified as a type of team according to Johnson, Katner, and Kikora?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Environmental improvement team

 

   

b) 

Departmental improvement team

 

   

c) 

Process improvement team

 

   

d) 

Task force

 

Question 27

Which of the following strategies counter the negative influences of advisor and followers?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Personal identity of members

 

   

b) 

Looking for disagreement among     advisors

 

   

c) 

Relationships among team members

 

   

d) 

Follower’s identity within the     organization

 

Question 28

Topics that are widely addressed in ethics training programs are:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

drug and alcohol abuse.

 

   

b) 

employee theft and sexual     harassment.

 

   

c) 

inaccuracy of books and records.

 

   

d) 

All of the above

 

Question 29

One of the strongest human motivators is:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

compensation.

 

   

b) 

group participation.

 

   

c) 

communication.

 

   

d) 

recognition.

 

Question 30

What percentage of what is seen is remembered and retained?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

50%

 

   

b) 

30%

 

   

c) 

90%

 

   

d) 

10%

 

Question 31

What percentage of what is read is remembered and retained?

Question options:

  

   

a) 

10 percent

 

   

b) 

20 percent

 

   

c) 

30 percent

 

   

d) 

50 percent

 

Question 32

________ communication is communication among groups.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

One-on-one level

 

   

b) 

Team-level

 

   

c) 

Company-level

 

   

d) 

Community-led

 

Question 33

__________ factors are a form of nonverbal communication that include tone, volume, and rate of speech.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Talking

 

   

b) 

Listening

 

   

c) 

Body

 

   

d) 

Voice

 

Question 34

A strategy used by internal politics that involves the sharing and/or selective withholding of information is:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

coalition building.

 

   

b) 

lobbying.

 

   

c) 

electioneering.

 

   

d) 

spreading of rumors and gossip.

 

Question 35

A strategy used by internal politics that involves the sharing and/or selective withholding of information is:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

coalition building.

 

   

b) 

lobbying.

 

   

c) 

electioneering.

 

   

d) 

the power play.

 

Question 36

Productive conflict is stimulated using methods such as:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

providing immediate feedback.

 

   

b) 

making sure team objectives     support the strategic directions of the organization.

 

   

c) 

requiring employees to identify     the downside when making suggestions.

 

   

d) 

instilling a focus on continuous     improvement.

 

Question 37

Controlling internal politics begins with the organization’s:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

mission.

 

   

b) 

vision.

 

   

c) 

strategic plan.

 

   

d) 

human resources.

 

Question 38

__________ is the best defense against negativity in organizations, and is the best tool for overcoming negativity that has set in.

Question options:

  

   

a) 

Consensus building

 

   

b) 

Communication

 

   

c) 

Role modeling

 

   

d) 

Root cause analysis

 

Question 39

Verbal communication is LEAST effective when:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

reprimanding an employee for     poor performance.

 

   

b) 

promoting a safety campaign.

 

   

c) 

commending an employee for doing     a good job.

 

   

d) 

attempting to resolve conflict     between or among employees.

 

Question 40

Robert Luke offers four guidelines for enhancing the effectiveness of corrective feedback. They are:

Question options:

  

   

a) 

be positive, be prepared, be     realistic, and don’t be completely negative.

 

   

b) 

be positive, be prepared, be     realistic, be accurate.

 

   

c) 

be direct, be prepared, be     realistic, be accurate.

 

   

d) 

don’t be completely negative, be     positive, be brief, and be understanding.

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

The Ceo Who Saved A Life And Lost His Job

PROJECT ONE “CASE STUDY” INSTRUCTIONS

Case Subject
“The CEO Who Saved a Life and Lost His Job” Please see the PDF file in the Project One folder.

Project Tasks

Please write an 8-10 pages’ long essay analyzing and discussing the following topics following the order of Tasks 1 to 6:

1. Task 1(5 points): Summarize the case. Length suggestion: 1 page. 2. Task 2 (15 points): Identify (list) the ethical issues that have arisen in this case. Please

offer some details about each ethical issue (e.g. including what’s occurred, who’s

affected, etc.). Length suggestion: 1 page.

3. Task 3 (20 points): Identify (list) all of the stakeholders of the company (i.e., Chimerix)

in the case, and discuss each of their viewpoints (e.g., needs, desires, concerns, costs,

benefits, power, etc.). Length suggestion: 1-2 pages.

MGMT4308 PROJECT ONE “CASE STUDY” INSTRUCTIONS

Case Subject “The CEO Who Saved a Life and Lost His Job” Please see the PDF file in the Project One folder.

Project Tasks

Please write an 8-10 pages’ long essay analyzing and discussing the following topics following the order of Tasks 1 to 6:

1. Task 1(5 points): Summarize the case. Length suggestion: 1 page.

2. Task 2 (15 points): Identify (list) the ethical issues that have arisen in this case. Please

offer some details about each ethical issue (e.g. including what’s occurred, who’s

affected, etc.). Length suggestion: 1 page.

3. Task 3 (20 points): Identify (list) all of the stakeholders of the company (i.e., Chimerix)

in the case, and discuss each of their viewpoints (e.g., needs, desires, concerns, costs,

benefits, power, etc.). Length suggestion: 1-2 pages.

4. Task 4 (20 points): Explain in detail which of the stakeholders should be involved and

helpful to solve the ethical issues that have arisen in the case, and why, given their

viewpoints. Length suggestion: 1-2 pages.

5. Task 5 (20 points): List all of the ethical theories and principles (i.e., 14 ethical

principles under the part “Principles of ethical conduct” from Page 228 in Chapter 8 of the textbook) that are appropriate for solving the ethical issues in this case. Explain in detail why each principle is appropriate for solving the particular ethical issue. Length suggestion: 2 pages.

6. Task 6 (20 points): Using certain ethical theories and principles to recommend a plan of action for the company that will help the company (i.e., Chimerix) remain competitive and avoid such problems in the future. Explain the expected positive and negative consequences of the plan of action you recommend. Length suggestion: 2 pages.

7. You will be given 5 bonus points for sending your draft to UHV writing center to improve your writing quality. UHV writing center tutoring service is free but reservation is needed. URL: UHV Writing Center website

1

Guidelines and Requirement

1. The length of your essay is about 8-10 pages (double-spaced, 12 pt “Times New Roman” font, 1-inch margins, excluding exhibits and references) in MS Word format.

2. Submission deadlines:

a. You need to submit your complete draft by March 29, 2020. a. Final submission due: April 26, 2020 11:59 PM through TurnItIn submission. Please

submit your final paper a few days before the deadline so that you can have time to revise if the similarity rate is high. You can have multiple submissions but only your last attempt will be graded.

3. Before you start, read the instructions and the case twice. You should also read the other files in the project one folder (on Blackboard) too.

4. You should not conduct outside research for the case analysis. In other words, you should pretend that you are facing exactly the same situation and information presented in the case.

5. Your answer should be specific to the six tasks specified above and follow the order to organize your analysis. Please keep in mind that those topics are actually interconnected. You need to integrate your answers into a report with smooth logic and internal consistency. You are suggested to use appropriate sub-titles to make your paper easier to follow.

6. The analysis must be professionally written. Don’t use bullet or lists. Write your answers in complete sentences. Please conduct spelling check, grammar check, and virus-check before submission.

7. Avoid laundry lists. Focus and organize your analysis. Look for frameworks from the readings or the textbook that help you organize and present your analysis.

8. Consider ‘turning the question’ into the beginning of your answer. That is, if the question is, “What are the key issues?” begin your answer with; “The key issues” (include or are). This may seem simplistic, but is a very effective way to help you focus your answer on the question(s) asked and to earn full credit. Don’t repeat the entire question in your answer.

9. You need to highlight the names of the ethical principles in your paper.

10. Please follow APA format for your writing (URL: APA Format website). Indicate any

2

references you cited in your report. The references list does NOT count for length

requirement purpose. 11. Not following instructions would result in point deduction.

Grading Standards and Rubrics

In grading your written assignments I use the following standards.

1. Rigor of analysis: You should use the appropriate frameworks from the class that are

germane to the problem.

2. Logical consistency: Your writing should be logically consistent from the beginning to

the end.

3. Depth of analysis and practical implications: Before making your own argument,

consider alternative explanations and solutions. Then try to justify your argument or

identify the situations under which some solutions are working better than others.

4. Clarity of writing: Papers should be addressed to a managerial audience. This means

that you should outline carefully, write clearly and concisely, and use appropriate tables

and graphics to support your argument, if necessary.

Please see attached page for the rubrics used in our course assessment.

Academic Honesty

1. The University’s policies related to academic honesty will be strictly enforced.

2. Your work on this assignment must be entirely your own. Your final submission is

subject to the similarity check by Turnitin.com (with the submission link available in the project folder later). A submission with 20% or higher similarity rate will receive a failing score.

3. Situations in which 2 or more students are alleged to have been involved in a conspiracy to cheat will be referred to the Provost and/or Academic Council as discussed in the Student Handbook.

4. By completing and submitting this assignment, you acknowledge that you have read, and have agreed to, the above rules relating to Academic Honesty.

 

 

 

 

 

 

The CEO who saved a life and lost his job

 

Companies/Industries

· Social media raises the stakes in the race for drug approvals

· If Josh dies, “how will Moch live w/himself?”

In early 2014, 7-year-old Josh Hardy was dying. He’d been battling kidney cancer since he was a baby and survived 10 intensive chemotherapy treatments, which severely weakened his immune system. Soon after undergoing a bone marrow stem cell transplant last January, he developed a life-threatening respiratory virus.

Chimerix, a small biotechnology company in Durham, N.C., had an experimental, unapproved drug in development that might help, Josh’s doctor at St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital told the boy’s family. They twice asked Chimerix to provide Josh the drug and were refused both times. “Please help us save our son,” his mother, Aimee, wrote on her Facebook page on March 6. “If anyone with influence can help us convince the Chimerix Inc to release the drug for compassionate care for our son, we would be forever grateful.”

Within several days, a #SaveJosh hashtag was trending on Twitter. A Facebook page set up for Josh’s cause registered 27,000 “likes” in one week. Social media posts supporting the family’s effort to get the drug were directed at Chimerix and its chief executive officer, Kenneth Moch, who also received thousands of e-mails and phone calls. If Josh dies, asked one tweet, “how will Moch live w/himself?” Another said that Moch’s decision to withhold the drug carried “a HEAVY Karmic price!” Yet another called Chimerix executives “cowards?… Ken Moch, I can only hope this doesn’t happen to your child.” And Moch was the target of death threats that the FBI deemed credible, so he and his wife moved out of their home for several days.

Under intense pressure, the company worked out a plan with the Food and Drug Administration to add a clinical trial for the drug, brincidofovir, and to enroll Josh as its first patient. “It was relatively an easier campaign because we had a very tangible goal,” says William Burns, Josh’s uncle, who first used the hashtag and set up the “Save Josh” Facebook page. “We had an immediate need, not like, ‘Give more money to cure cancer 10 years from now.’”

While the question of whether to give Josh the drug seemed like a no-brainer to his family and supporters, it presented Chimerix with tricky issues to sort out. Compassionate use—formally known as expanded access—allows experimental drugs that haven’t been approved by the FDA to be given to patients in life-or-death situations who have no other treatment options. While the FDA is required to sign off on compassionate-use cases—it usually approves about 1,000 a year—the decision about whether to give out an unapproved drug rests with drugmakers. A patient’s physician typically requests a drug from the company developing it. The company weighs several factors, including the most potentially tragic—that the drug might hasten or cause the death of a patient. Such a death can complicate a company’s efforts to secure FDA approval and to ultimately make the drug widely available.

For a small biotech like Chimerix, which had no product on the market and no source of revenue, handing out experimental drugs, usually for free, can be especially costly. Compassionate use also can delay the FDA approval process, because drugs and other resources are diverted to patients who aren’t enrolled in formal trials, which collect data necessary for gaining regulatory approval.

“Everyone asks this question,” Moch says. “‘If it were my child, would I do what the Hardys did?’ Absolutely, yes.” But that wasn’t his role, he says. “As the CEO, I have to think not just about the individual, but the many.”

On April 9, three weeks after Josh got into the brincidofovir trial, Moch stepped down as CEO. The company says he resigned. Moch says he was replaced and can’t comment in detail about his departure other than to say he would have “loved to continue to be CEO, but the board felt otherwise.” Chimerix declined to comment beyond its press release announcing Moch’s departure and his replacement. “We are now entering a critical stage of the clinical development of brincidofovir,” the release said. “Our goal is to complete the requirements for regulatory approval of brincidofovir as rapidly as possible.”

Moch, 60, joined Chimerix as CEO in 2010. He studied biochemistry as an undergraduate at Princeton and had worked in the life sciences industry since getting his MBA from Stanford in 1980. In 1982 he co-founded Liposome, a developer of treatments for cancer, including breast cancer; drugmaker Elan acquired Liposome in 2000. Moch held various executive-level positions with medical companies before joining Chimerix.

Last year, when Chimerix was approached for help by the Hardy family, the company had 55 employees, no approved drugs, and was relying on funds from investors. It was in the final phase of testing brincidofovir for FDA approval to market the drug to prevent cytomegalovirus in bone marrow stem cell transplant patients. Chimerix also had tested brincidofovir as a preventive therapy for adenovirus, the virus afflicting Josh, in an earlier stage of the trial. At the end of March 2014, the company had an accumulated deficit of $173 million since its founding in 2000, according to regulatory filings.

Chimerix had previously given brincidofovir to 430 patients for compassionate use in a program funded in part by the government. When funding ran out in 2012, Chimerix closed the program to focus on getting the drug through the FDA, Moch says. Allocating any available doses to Josh could have slowed that process, he says. “It’s horribly conflicting,” he says of the dilemma he faced in March. “You go into this business to saves lives.”

Some patient advocates insist that companies have a moral obligation to make their drugs available to desperately ill patients. “Here’s a kid where it’s life or death, hanging on to Ken Moch’s decision,” says Nancy Goodman, executive director of Kids v Cancer, a nonprofit advocacy group for children with cancer which helped publicize the Hardy family’s campaign. “It’s profoundly unethical for him not to give the drug.”

Kevin Donovan, director of the Center for Clinical Bioethics at the Georgetown University Medical Center, says the conflict between companies and patients lies in a clash of responsibilities. “The company’s obligation is the greatest good for the greatest number,” he says. “If it’s your loved one, if it’s you, if you’re a patient, your moral obligation is to the welfare of that individual.” Both approaches are legitimate, he says.

These complexities get lost in a social media maelstrom, says Darshak Sanghavi, an associate professor at the University of Massachusetts Medical School who’s conducted research on compassionate-use issues. “I think that whenever you have 140 characters to describe a complicated medical decision, it’s going to be oversimplified—‘there’s a dying child, why won’t the drug company give the drug?’” Sanghavi says. “It’s so easily amplified, and any nuance, even if it was present early on, rapidly gets rubbed out,” he says.

James Greenwood, CEO of the Biotechnology Industry Organization (BIO), says social media’s role in the Hardy case unnerved the industry. “When you add social media and start tweeting all over the place, then reason flies out of the window,” says Greenwood. “Social media creates opinion storms, we all know that.”

Moch stresses that in the end, Josh’s brincidofovir treatment was not compassionate use. As part of a new clinical trial, his response to the drug was included in data Chimerix was gathering in its push for FDA approval. The trial tested brincidofovir as a treatment for adenovirus, not just a preventive therapy. Barring any delays, the FDA could approve the drug by the end of 2016.

Moch’s point is one that matters deeply to small biotech companies trying to get their first drug to market. One example, says BIO’s Greenwood, is CytRx, a biotech whose trials for its experimental cancer drug aldoxorubi-cin were temporarily placed on hold on Nov. 18 after the death of a patient who received the medication under compassionate use. The potential for the FDA to stop a trial because of a patient death or some adverse event outside the scope of a trial, for which patients are carefully screened, could further deter biotechs from giving out their drugs, Greenwood says.

BIO is working with its member companies, particularly small ones, to prepare for campaigns like the one the Hardy family waged against Chimerix and Moch. The group suggests that members make it clear how a compassionate-use program will operate and develop a crisis management plan.

About a week after receiving brincidofovir, Josh’s mother reported on her blog that his condition had improved dramatically; he was discharged from the hospital in early April. Moch says he’s in active discussions to take a new CEO job. He’s spent the past nine months meeting regularly with chief executives of other small companies about compassionate use issues and consulting for a working group of ethicists at New York University’s Langone Medical Center that’s studying the challenges of compassionate use.

“For the biotech community, what happened to Moch was a shock,” says Greenwood. “Within the BIO board and in our community, Ken Moch is a very loved person. People were hurt to see what happened to him, and they worried that this could be me.”

32,478

tweets worldwide using #savejosh from Jan. 16, 2014, to Jan. 16, 2015

57%

Urgent requests on behalf of patients who could die within hours

The bottom line Biotechs have watched closely the experience of Chimerix, the target of a social media campaign.

GRAPH: Last Resort Requests granted by the FDA for compassionate use of a drug, in the 12 months ended Sept. 30

PHOTO (COLOR): Former Chimerix CEO Moch

 

Copyright of Bloomberg Businessweek is the property of Bloomberg, L.P. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder’s express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.

 
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"