solution
In 2011, the Boston Globe reported that three high-volume betting
groups, the MIT group, the Michigan group, and the Boston &
Northeastern Universities group, have been monopolizing Cash Winfall, a
state lottery of Massachusetts. This report triggered an investigation
on these groups as well as the Massachusetts State Lottery. There was no
illegal activities found for all three groups and they each walked away
with multi-million dollars, however, Cash Winfall was shut down after
its last drawing on January 26, 2012 due to its flaw in design. The goal
of this project is to understand how these betting groups gamed the
Massachusetts lottery system using probability theory. Cash Winfall was
drawn on Mondays and Thursdays. Each ticket costed $2 and a player chose
six distinct numbers from 1 to 46, ex: 1,9, 17,23, 39, 40. To win the
jackpot, these numbers must match all six of the numbered balls that
drop out of the bin during a drawing. The minimum jackpot was $500,000
and could be higher depending on the lottery sales. The game also
offered smaller prizes: $4,000 for matching five out of six numbers;
$150 for matching four out of six; $5 for matching three of six; and a
free $2 bet for matching two of the drawn numbers. There are two ways to
pick six numbers. A player can hand-pick six distinct numbers out of
1-46. Or, a lottery printing machine can be used to print a ticket. In
the latter case, the lottery machine picks a random combination (all
combinations are equally likely each time the computer prints a ticket).
The Massachusetts State Lottery (the Lottery in short) designed Cash
WinFall to add 60 cents of every dollar wagered to the jackpot, leaving
40 cents for the Lottery to run its own operations and distribute to
cities and towns in the form of local aid. Like all lottery games, Cash
WinFall is designed to make money for the Lottery (and a net loss for
the player) and the more Cash Winfall tickets the Lottery sold, the more
money the Lottery made. Because the probability of matching all six
numbers is very low, the jackpot was rarely claimed. In this case, like
most lotteries, the jackpot was rolled over to the next period. In the
very rare case of multiple winners, the jackpot was supposed to be split
into the number of winners. However, in the history of Cash Winfall,
that had never happened. However, Cash WinFall had a feature that
distinguished it from other lotteries: the jackpot was capped at $2
million. If the jackpot reached $2 million and no one matched all six
numbers, the money in the jackpot was distributed among the lower
tier prizes for that drawing. The Lottery referred to this as a
“roll-down†and it dramatically boosted payouts for lower tier prizes.
Cash WinFall replaced Mass Millions, a game that lost players when it
didn’t produce a single jackpot winner in 2003. The Cash WinFall
roll-downs were designed to generate excitement and ticket sales even if
no one ever won the jackpot, and it worked. The rolldowns were a topic
of conversation on online forums like lotterypost.com. The Lottery
published the predicted amount of jackpot of each game. The players
flocked to Cash WinFall whenever the Lottery predicted a possibility of
roll-down (over $2M jackpot). Here’s how a typical roll-down worked. The
drawing held on Feb. 4, 2010 had a jackpot of $1,631,236. No one
matched all six numbers so the jackpot pool was carried over for the
next drawing. By the next morning, the Lottery had estimated the Cash
WinFall jackpot for the Feb. 8 drawing at $2 million, meaning bettors
could expect a roll-down provided no one matched all six numbers and
claimed the entire jackpot. As was typical for drawings with anticipated
roll-downs, wagering was heavy resulting $2.4M jackpot by the drawing
on Feb 8. And, guess what, no one hit the jackpot. As a result, that
money rolled down to the next three lower prize levels using a formula
developed by the Lottery when it created the game in 2004. Of the $2.4
million in the Feb. 8 jackpot, 26 percent- about $633,383 – went to
boost the payout for those matching five out of six numbers. Instead of
receiving the standard $4,000 prize, holders of the 35 tickets matching
five out of six numbers received $22,096- the $4,000 standard payout
plus a 1/35th share of the $633,383 in roll-down money dedicated to this
tier. Similarly, 47 percent of the $2.4 million – about $1,158,000 –
was used to enhance the prize for those matching four out of six
numbers. Holders of the 1,761 tickets matching four of six numbers
received $807.52, instead of the standard payout of $150. For those
matching three out of six numbers, about 27 percent of the jackpot –
$652,000 – rolled down to increase the payout. Lottery records show
there were 29,832 tickets matching three of six numbers. Each one was
worth $26.85 instead of the standard $5 prize. Lottery records also
indicate that just over 209,000 tickets matched two of the six numbers
drawn, entitling the holder to a free $2 bet (the prize stays the same
for matching two of the drawn numbers). Normally, a lottery is designed
so that the expected payoff (prize – cost) is always negative (your
expected prize money is less than the cost of the lottery). However, the
unique rule of Cash WinFall created an opportunity for the three
betting groups mentioned earlier to rig the Cash WinFall to obtain a
positive expected payoff.
clearly show each presenter. Please submit either the mp4 file of the
video or a link to recording along with your project report on Canvas.
groups, the MIT group, the Michigan group, and the Boston &
Northeastern Universities group, have been monopolizing Cash Winfall, a
state lottery of Massachusetts. This report triggered an investigation
on these groups as well as the Massachusetts State Lottery. There was no
illegal activities found for all three groups and they each walked away
with multi-million dollars, however, Cash Winfall was shut down after
its last drawing on January 26, 2012 due to its flaw in design. The goal
of this project is to understand how these betting groups gamed the
Massachusetts lottery system using probability theory. Cash Winfall was
drawn on Mondays and Thursdays. Each ticket costed $2 and a player chose
six distinct numbers from 1 to 46, ex: 1,9, 17,23, 39, 40. To win the
jackpot, these numbers must match all six of the numbered balls that
drop out of the bin during a drawing. The minimum jackpot was $500,000
and could be higher depending on the lottery sales. The game also
offered smaller prizes: $4,000 for matching five out of six numbers;
$150 for matching four out of six; $5 for matching three of six; and a
free $2 bet for matching two of the drawn numbers. There are two ways to
pick six numbers. A player can hand-pick six distinct numbers out of
1-46. Or, a lottery printing machine can be used to print a ticket. In
the latter case, the lottery machine picks a random combination (all
combinations are equally likely each time the computer prints a ticket).
The Massachusetts State Lottery (the Lottery in short) designed Cash
WinFall to add 60 cents of every dollar wagered to the jackpot, leaving
40 cents for the Lottery to run its own operations and distribute to
cities and towns in the form of local aid. Like all lottery games, Cash
WinFall is designed to make money for the Lottery (and a net loss for
the player) and the more Cash Winfall tickets the Lottery sold, the more
money the Lottery made. Because the probability of matching all six
numbers is very low, the jackpot was rarely claimed. In this case, like
most lotteries, the jackpot was rolled over to the next period. In the
very rare case of multiple winners, the jackpot was supposed to be split
into the number of winners. However, in the history of Cash Winfall,
that had never happened. However, Cash WinFall had a feature that
distinguished it from other lotteries: the jackpot was capped at $2
million. If the jackpot reached $2 million and no one matched all six
numbers, the money in the jackpot was distributed among the lower
tier prizes for that drawing. The Lottery referred to this as a
“roll-down†and it dramatically boosted payouts for lower tier prizes.
Cash WinFall replaced Mass Millions, a game that lost players when it
didn’t produce a single jackpot winner in 2003. The Cash WinFall
roll-downs were designed to generate excitement and ticket sales even if
no one ever won the jackpot, and it worked. The rolldowns were a topic
of conversation on online forums like lotterypost.com. The Lottery
published the predicted amount of jackpot of each game. The players
flocked to Cash WinFall whenever the Lottery predicted a possibility of
roll-down (over $2M jackpot). Here’s how a typical roll-down worked. The
drawing held on Feb. 4, 2010 had a jackpot of $1,631,236. No one
matched all six numbers so the jackpot pool was carried over for the
next drawing. By the next morning, the Lottery had estimated the Cash
WinFall jackpot for the Feb. 8 drawing at $2 million, meaning bettors
could expect a roll-down provided no one matched all six numbers and
claimed the entire jackpot. As was typical for drawings with anticipated
roll-downs, wagering was heavy resulting $2.4M jackpot by the drawing
on Feb 8. And, guess what, no one hit the jackpot. As a result, that
money rolled down to the next three lower prize levels using a formula
developed by the Lottery when it created the game in 2004. Of the $2.4
million in the Feb. 8 jackpot, 26 percent- about $633,383 – went to
boost the payout for those matching five out of six numbers. Instead of
receiving the standard $4,000 prize, holders of the 35 tickets matching
five out of six numbers received $22,096- the $4,000 standard payout
plus a 1/35th share of the $633,383 in roll-down money dedicated to this
tier. Similarly, 47 percent of the $2.4 million – about $1,158,000 –
was used to enhance the prize for those matching four out of six
numbers. Holders of the 1,761 tickets matching four of six numbers
received $807.52, instead of the standard payout of $150. For those
matching three out of six numbers, about 27 percent of the jackpot –
$652,000 – rolled down to increase the payout. Lottery records show
there were 29,832 tickets matching three of six numbers. Each one was
worth $26.85 instead of the standard $5 prize. Lottery records also
indicate that just over 209,000 tickets matched two of the six numbers
drawn, entitling the holder to a free $2 bet (the prize stays the same
for matching two of the drawn numbers). Normally, a lottery is designed
so that the expected payoff (prize – cost) is always negative (your
expected prize money is less than the cost of the lottery). However, the
unique rule of Cash WinFall created an opportunity for the three
betting groups mentioned earlier to rig the Cash WinFall to obtain a
positive expected payoff.
clearly show each presenter. Please submit either the mp4 file of the
video or a link to recording along with your project report on Canvas.
1. Suppose you purchased a single $2 Cash WinFall ticket. What’s the
probability of winning the first place, second, third, fourth, and
fifth? What’s the probability of winning nothing at all?
probability of winning the first place, second, third, fourth, and
fifth? What’s the probability of winning nothing at all?
2. Suppose that
450,000 Cash WinFall tickets were sold for the Jan 29th drawing. Six
winning balls were drawn. What’s the probability of having two winners
of the jackpot? Assume all 450,000 tickets were printed by the lottery
machine that randomly picks the numbers on each betting slip with equal
probability.
450,000 Cash WinFall tickets were sold for the Jan 29th drawing. Six
winning balls were drawn. What’s the probability of having two winners
of the jackpot? Assume all 450,000 tickets were printed by the lottery
machine that randomly picks the numbers on each betting slip with equal
probability.
3. Continued from #2, the Jan 29th drawing’s jackpot is
announced to be $1,060,000 ($540,000 from new sales + $520,000 rolled
over from the last drawing. Treating the $2 free betting as the
equivalent dollar payoff, compute the expected payoff of your single $2
ticket. Is it worth investing in the lottery given the expected payoff?
announced to be $1,060,000 ($540,000 from new sales + $520,000 rolled
over from the last drawing. Treating the $2 free betting as the
equivalent dollar payoff, compute the expected payoff of your single $2
ticket. Is it worth investing in the lottery given the expected payoff?
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

