solution
CONTRASTING CHINA’S YUNAN MODEL WITH BANGLADESH’S YUNUS MODEL FOR MICROFINANCE
Source: Yuping Du, Randall O. Chang, Meng Wu and Chun Li, 2013, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation
Note: certain names and other identifying information may have been disguised
China’s “Yunan Model” began in 2008 in Yunan County, a less developed rural area in the mountainous regions of western Guangdong Province, a province known for its political stability and social harmony. Although the citizens of Yunan County were considered poor, there was no shortages of food and clothing, farmers had ample land for agricultural production and their economic values were unhampered by religious beliefs. This area of poverty was characterized by three factors: no loans, no collateral from borrowers and no credit information system to encourage banks to make loans to people in the community. The government-appointed Yunan Committee decided to promote microloans (small loans to people with no credit history) in order to stimulate economic development. As the economy developed, it was envisioned that there would be increased business opportunities for the financially disadvantaged.
The Yunan Committee believed that it was not only free market forces but also the hand of government guidance that was needed to jump-start the rural economy. Three specific objectives were pursued: to create a credit information system, to establish credit villages and to provide financial assistance to poor people as the main vehicle for financial reform.
Financial reform in the countryside resulted in the growth of credit and an improved social environment. The government’s administration became more effective, and the government was credited with positively contributing to peoples’ lives.
The Yunan model was known to treat women and men equally, with every financial institution devoted to one village, as for funding, the model had several funding sources including charitable donations. Farmers were given loans to develop their farming and animal husbandry with every village developing one product; as for the loan amount it varied between RMB2,000 to RMB50,000 with longer repayment periods of up to three years. Borrowers, credit village and credit information centre plan and develop collective assessments and incentive ratings for borrowers and villages alike; loan repayments encouraged through village pressure. What was unique about the Yunan model is that the Poverty alleviation unit helped to pay loan interest, as much as 90 per cent, leaving poor households to pay 10 per cent of interest.
The Government played an important role in coordinating with different parties.
Looking at the results of the Yunan model, we could clearly see the following,
Loan repayments were very successful, enabling borrowers to leave poverty; in addition to a very supportive government; the Government consolidated various financial institutions and social funds to establish Yunan County Financial Fund; the pooled funds were used to make loans in order to alleviate need for start-up capital for farmers and small businesses, borrowers also benefit not only from receiving credit but also by contributing to the improved and harmonious social environment brought about by increased morality and good values
The Model’s plan as a whole to improve the economy and society was also successful, the model was able to combine goals of providing financial service, developing economic growth, and improving social conditions; supported by the government’s overall plan to help all quarters of the society
Beginning in 1983, Muhammad Yunus’s Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, a country known for its social unrest, political instability, extreme poverty, widespread unemployment, Muslim population (80%) with economic values influenced by religious beliefs and heavy rain floods causing economic losses, had changed the rules of traditional banking by pioneering the idea of making loans to “unqualified” poor people. It was a good balance between market capitalism and public welfare. However, because of its high interest rates, lack of government support and conflicts with the Bangladesh government, Grameen Bank’s role as a model ended in 2011.
The Yunus model, gave loans mostly to women with families who want to escape poverty, including beggars; borrowers are also depositors and shareholders; Loans are mostly for small handicraft or household sideline businesses, generating rapid but volatile income, prior to 1995, loans were funded by charitable giving; after 1995, loans were funded by the bank’s internal resources. The loans were relatively small, around RMB2,000 with short repayment period: weekly with final maturity in one year.
As for the guarantee, five families jointly guarantee a loan; with a mutual monitoring system established between friends to form a common bond to encourage loan repayments through social pressure. In the beginning, loan interest rate was lower than the government rate but new branches were required to be profitable in their first year of operation; later, interest rose to 20 per cent, and was paid entirely by the borrower.
The results of the Yunus model: Borrower’s found it hard to be lifted out of poverty and the bank was pulled into political conflicts. At the beginning funding was from charitable donations and customer savings after 1998 when donations were no longer accepted interest rates rose to 20 and 50%. The plan to improve the economy and society failed because the bank was too large and bureaucratic with slow reaction time and limited attention to meeting borrower needs in addition to that they used high interest rates and pressure for debt repayments in order to enable financial viability as a commercial bank; and the founder was accused of bad ethics for his exploitation of the poor in the guise of poverty alleviation
Question 2:
Compare and contrast the Grameen Bank model with the Yunan Model. Use the below table to help you identify differences (Table 1). (70 marks, around 200 words)
TABLE 1: DIFFERENCES BETWEEN YUNUS (OR GRAMEEN MODEL) AND YUNAN MODEL
|
(7 marks for every variable) |
Yunus Model |
Yunan Model |
|
Political Background |
||
|
EconomicEnvironment |
||
|
CulturalEnvironment |
||
|
ProspectiveBorrower and Identity |
||
|
Loans are given to support which kind of needs? |
||
|
Line of Credit |
||
|
RepaymentSchedule |
||
|
Guarantee |
||
|
Loan Interest rate |
||
|
GovernmentSupport |
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

