solution
- In terms of power and influence (e.g. dependency relationships, bases of power, influence tactics), what do you think would be the most effective or most important for driving change?
CASE STUDY : JUST WASH YOUR HANDS
In early 2011, Sarah Noble, a fourth-year science student at Western University Canada in London,
Ontario, was reviewing her recommendations to improve the hand-cleaning compliance of the London
Health Science Centre’s (LHSC) medical and support staff. Noble’s research and report was created for
the manager of Infection Prevention and Control and constituted one of her assignments for her cooperative placement. It was well known that cleaning hands was an effective measure to reduce hospital acquired infections. In 2007, LHSC had been part of a pilot project called “Just Clean Your Hands,” and
although hand-washing conformance had been improving since its launch, hand-hygiene compliance rates
were not meeting the targets set by the Province’s Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care.
Changing the culture and behaviour of the staff was turning out to be a tremendous challenge that
required a thorough understanding of organizational behaviour. Noble needed to provide her
recommendations to the hospital administration within the week so that an effective plan of action could
be put in place. She sighed. It was going to be a long week.
Ontario Health Care5 and LHSC
Hospitals in Ontario were publicly funded and accountable to the Province’s Ministry of Health and
Long-Term Care. There were 227 hospitals in the province. The London Health Sciences Centre was a
large regional hospital with an annual budget of approximately $1 billion. It admitted more than 41,000
patients each year. There were several different employee groups working at LHSC, including
physicians, nurses, clerical staff and volunteers. In total, 14,295 people worked at LHSC in various
capacities at one or more of its three campuses: University Hospital, Victoria Hospital and South Street
Hospital. Many of these groups had contact with patients. Although most of these groups were
employees of the hospital, physicians generally were not employees and, instead, charged a fee for their
services to the Ontario Health Insurance Plan6 (see Exhibit 1 for a complete list of employee
classifications at LHSC). Health-care staff came into contact with patients through a range of tasks, from
helping patients become comfortable in bed to taking a patient’s pulse. These activities had the potential
to transfer many thousands of micro-organisms to the hands of a health-care staff member or to a patient.
HANDWASHING7
The Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care had developed a detailed hand-washing training program for
hospital staff throughout the province. The program was called “Just Clean Your Hands.” A person who
would be coming into contact with a patient was required to follow the hand-washing protocols. The list
included physicians, nurses and other health-care professionals, such as physical therapists and dieticians,
housekeeping staff members and the patient’s visitors.
When to Clean Hands8
Health-care experts had determined that there were four situations when hospital staff needed to clean
their hands. Referred to as “the four moments of care,” these moments were:
• Moment 1 — Before initial contact with a patient or with the patient’s environment, including
furniture, clothing, medical devices, telephones and any personal items. This step was to protect the
patient from harmful micro-organisms carried on a staff member’s hands.
• Moment 2 — Before aseptic procedures.9 This step helped prevent germs that were on the health-care
worker or on the patient from entering the patient’s body.
• Moment 3 — After body fluid exposure risk. This step included glove removal and ensured that the
medical staff member was protected against harmful bacteria and viruses.
• Moment 4 — After contact with a patient or with the patient’s environment.
How to Clean Hands
Hand washing to prevent HAI required the use of soap and water or an alcohol-based rub. As well,
fingernails needed to be clipped short because long nails could harbour more micro-organisms, and nail
polish could not be used since it could increase the number of micro-organisms in the nails. Rings,
bracelets and watches could not be worn by staff who came in direct contact with patients.
When using soap, staff members were to wet their hands with warm water, apply liquid soap and
vigorously lather for at least 15 seconds. The soap had to be removed thoroughly by rinsing their hands
well. Their hands needed to be dried with a paper towel and the taps turned off using paper towel to
prevent recontamination of their hands.
If an alcohol-based hand rub was used, the staff member’s hands had to be visibly clean. Hands soiled
with food, dirt, or other contaminants could not be cleaned using alcohol rubs. Instead, staff were to
apply one or two pumps of solution to their hands and then spread the solution over the entire surface of
their hands, rubbing for at least 15 seconds or until their hands were dry.
COMPLIANCE DATA
The Rates
Historically, LHSC had very poor hand-washing compliance rates. However, the rate of compliance had
been improving since the launch of the “Just Clean Your Hands” pilot project in 2007 as the organization
focused on the problem.
In some locations, tremendous improvements had been made. For example, LHSC’s Victoria campus had
moved from 13 per cent in 2008 to 74 per cent in 2010 for Moment 1 compliance. However, across all of
its campuses, LHSC still had between 20 per cent and 30 per cent non-compliance. This data was
particularly troubling, since it was gathered using observers who were trained to follow staff and record
hand-cleaning conformance; consequently, the staff would usually be aware that the observer was present
and could alter their behaviour while being observed. The Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care
required that these rates be published. Exhibit 2 summarizes compliance rates for LHSC. Exhibit 3 lists
compliance rates at selected Ontario health-care organizations. Although LHSC was doing relatively well
compared to other organizations in the province, it wanted to improve compliance towards 100 per cent.
Ineffective hand cleaning (such as not scrubbing long enough) continued to be an issue affecting overall
compliance. The Vancouver Island Health Authority in British Columbia had found that nurses, for
example, attempted to comply with hygiene requirements 50 per cent of the time, but because their hand
washing was not done properly due to the wearing of rings, bracelets and nail polish, actual compliance
was reduced to 33 per cent. Hand-washing compliance also tended to vary by profession. Physicians had
different compliance levels than housekeeping staff, for example. Exhibit 4 provides a summary of handwashing compliance by profession.
Factors Leading to Non-Compliance
There were several reasons for poor hand-hygiene compliance:
1. Workload was one of the primary problems. Compliance of 100 per cent to the four moments could
take a significant amount of time, and hospital staff was often very busy. If staff members were in a
hurry or rushed, proper hand cleaning was sometimes rushed or skipped altogether.
2. Proper conformance to requirements could necessitate hand cleaning many dozens of times each day.
This could cause irritation or dryness to the staff’s hands.
3. The location of sinks or alcohol rub dispensers was inconvenient. To address this, many dispensers
had been installed throughout the sites in patients’ rooms, on stretchers and on wheel chairs.
4. Staff members were generally hesitant to speak up if they observed others not conforming to hand cleaning procedures and often preferred to avoid such confrontations.
5. Some religious beliefs had prevented the use of alcohol-based rubs.
6. Medical practitioners and support staff had established behaviours that were difficult to change. It
was thought that some individuals perceived that the infection risk linked to hand hygiene was not
serious enough to warrant the inconvenience of proper conformance. This attitude was somewhat
analogous to a driver’s use of a cell phone while driving a car. Although drivers were generally
aware that this distracting activity was dangerous to oneself and to others, it was still frequently done;
that is, the driver perceived the risk to be minimal relative to the inconvenience of not using the
device.
7. Visitors were often unaware of proper hand-cleaning procedures or chose to not follow the
procedures.
8. There was no mechanism for the discipline of physicians and other staff for failure to follow hand hygiene procedures. Many members of LHSC’s staff were unionized and, because the physicians
were not employees but contractors, discipline was a difficult issue. The discipline of physicians,
viewed as highly trained professionals and specialists in their fields, for an issue like hand hygiene
had never been a part of this professional group’s culture and would likely be viewed with disdain.
GOING FORWARD
Noble turned on her iPad and started reviewing her analysis to this point. She needed a plan to reinforce
the change in behaviour and culture that had started with the Just Clean Your Hands program and to
overcome the obstacles that she knew reduced hand-hygiene compliance rates. How could the staff be
motivated to continue to do better? There were so many employee groups, each with different
subcultures and compliance issues. What needed to be communicated? Who needed to get the message,
and who needed to deliver it? What sort of leadership style and approach would be most effective?
In terms of data collection, how should the compliance rates be monitored? In the past, LHSC had hired
and trained students to do the hand-hygiene audits. How much, if at all, did their presence change the
results? Noble had read that a hospital in the United States had tested the use of a “compliance checking
chip.” This device, worn by health-care practitioners, collected hand-hygiene data for each wearer and
could be used to coach or discipline employees who did not comply with hand-cleaning procedures. She
wondered about the implications of using such a device at LHSC.
The manager of Infection and Prevention Control had been clear to Noble that LHSC was on a fixed
budget, and any new initiative would need to be cost-effective and well justified. With these thoughts in
mind, she began to work in earnest on her proposal.
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

